Closes near, opens far
A reed switch lets go at a weaker field than the one that closed it: the sheet puts the release at 35 to 90 % of the pull-in. With a magnet that means it can stay closed until the magnet is some 40 % farther away than where it closed. That gap is why a slow magnet gives one clean change, and it is why a sensor has to be tested both ways.
Two distances, not one
Close the switch and the blades are touching, with a much smaller gap for the field to cross than when they were apart. It takes less field to hold them together than to pull them together. So the switch closes at one field and lets go at a lower one.
Start far away and slide the magnet in: the switch closes where the field reaches the pull-in. Now slide it back out slowly. It stays closed past that point, through the orange zone, and lets go only where the field has fallen far enough. Move back in from there and it stays open until the pull-in again. Inside the orange zone, the reading depends on which way the magnet came.
What the sheet promises
RMCIP's sheet for the MKA-14103 gives the release as a ratio: the switch lets go once the field has fallen to between 0.35 and 0.9 of what closed it. It does not say where in that range one switch falls, so plan for the widest gap. If a magnet's field falls as the cube of the distance, as a small magnet's roughly does away from its face, 0.35 of the field is 1.42 times as far: the switch can stay closed until the magnet is some 40 % farther away than where it closed.
The figure's millimetres belong to a model magnet that closes the switch at 15 mm. The ratio does not: it holds whatever the magnet.
Why this helps
The gap is called hysteresis, and it is the reason a slowly drifting magnet gives one clean change instead of flickering. Without it, a magnet sitting exactly at the threshold would close and open on every tremor. With it, the magnet has to move back a real distance before the switch changes its mind.
The cost is that "closed" does not mean "the magnet is as close as when it closed". For a door, set the magnet close enough that the door's normal shut position is well inside the closing distance, and a small opening takes it well past the letting-go distance.
When it does not work
No, that is what the sheet describes: it lets go once the field has fallen to between 35 and 90 % of what closed it. Test a mounting by moving the magnet away as well as toward the switch.
The magnet is inside the hold zone: too far to close the switch from open, not far enough to let it go. Move the magnet closer to the glass when the door is shut, so that a crack takes it well past where it lets go.
Nobody can say without the magnet: the switch's sheet gives the field it needs, not a distance. Hold it to the glass and pull it slowly away while watching the LED, then bring it back in and watch again. The two points are your close and open distances.
Counting openings, debounced, and timing how long each one lasts.
A door that counts →Edit this page — content/books/reed-switch/closes-near-opens-far.mdx
Questions about this product
See what other owners have asked, and read their solutions.
Reed Switch
Loading discussions…
Discuss this article
Ask about this page. The answer stays here, on the page it belongs to, for whoever hits the same wall next.